
Judge this Poem

User Info
 Welcome Anonymous
Membership:
 Latest: stumto
 New Today: 0
 New Yesterday: 0
 Overall: 16645
People Online:
 Members: 1
 Visitors: 50
 Bots: 2
 Staff: 0
Staff Online:No staff currently online.

Paid Membership
Buy a paid membership and get more out of GotPoetry!
Advertise on the GotPoetry Advertising Network.

Donations
 GotPoetry is a community supported site.
Due Date:
May 31
May Goal:
180.00
Gross Amount:
0.00
PayPal Fees:
0.00
Net Balance:
0.00
Below Goal:
180.00
Site Currency:
USD

Top Poetry Clubs
|
Forums > > Poetry Workshops > > Post a poem > > Comments, reflections, suggestions? rewrites OK too--Thanks!
Comments, reflections, suggestions? rewrites OK too--Thanks!
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Pujakins Poet


    
Joined: Jun 19, 2010 Posts: 1068 Credits: 206 Location: North Grafton MA

|
Posted: Tue May 29 18:47:49 EDT 2012 Post subject: Comments, reflections, suggestions? rewrites OK too--Thanks! |
|
Beyond our knowing,
stars move through the sky,
and heaven sweeps up the tears of love
making rainbows to comfort the woebegone.
Beyond our knowing,
birds sing the sun down and up
wind sweeps up the day's dust
readying the world for sleep.
Beyond our knowing
time ticks off our years,
until we're done with sunrise and sunset
becoming one with all that is together.
Beyond our knowing
Spiders spin, life moves in rivers
all adown the ways to be
while we in our littleness flow with its tide.
_________________ Maintaining an attitude of gratitude is the the best way I know to have a rich, fulfilling life. |
|
Karma: 3823.30 
Back to top |
|
 |
Ozymandias Site Curator


        
Joined: Apr 09, 2009 Posts: 1903 Credits: 230 Location: Near Melbourne, Australia

|
Posted: Wed May 30 4:05:55 EDT 2012 Post subject: Re: Comments, reflections, suggestions? rewrites OK too--Thanks! |
|
This is a very beautiful poem, one of your best. Just a couple of small things:
S3L4 seems rather awkward, it's difficult for me to give a meaning to the phrase "all that is together", and "becoming one with" is a phrase that's been overused, almost a cliche nowadays.
Likewise S4L3 is a bit hard to interpret and the word "adown" is unfamiliar to me.
_________________ No matter how finely you slice something up, it always has two sides. |
|
Karma: 13164.80 
Back to top |
|
 |
Pujakins Poet


    
Joined: Jun 19, 2010 Posts: 1068 Credits: 206 Location: North Grafton MA

|
Posted: Wed May 30 21:02:04 EDT 2012 Post subject: Re: Comments, reflections, suggestions? rewrites OK too--Thanks! |
|
How's this work for that troublesome verse? I like it better myself.
Beyond our knowing
time ticks off our years,
until we're done with sunrise and sunset
adding our bit of dust to all the rest.
Adown is just an archaic word I remember from my days as a folk singer, I believe it is another form of down. I simply liked the sound of it. Do you think it is too strange? I can drop the a. Thanks for your help and your commenting. Warmly, Tasha
_________________ Maintaining an attitude of gratitude is the the best way I know to have a rich, fulfilling life. |
|
Karma: 3823.30 
Back to top |
|
 |
Ozymandias Site Curator


        
Joined: Apr 09, 2009 Posts: 1903 Credits: 230 Location: Near Melbourne, Australia

|
Posted: Wed May 30 21:25:59 EDT 2012 Post subject: Re: Comments, reflections, suggestions? rewrites OK too--Thanks! |
|
| Pujakins wrote: |
How's this work for that troublesome verse? I like it better myself.
Beyond our knowing
time ticks off our years,
until we're done with sunrise and sunset
adding our bit of dust to all the rest.
Adown is just an archaic word I remember from my days as a folk singer, I believe it is another form of down. I simply liked the sound of it. Do you think it is too strange? I can drop the a. Thanks for your help and your commenting. Warmly, Tasha |
That's a big improvement to S3. Changing "adown" to "down" is better for me, although I still have a problem understanding "all down the ways to be" - perhaps "down all the ways to be" might work better?
_________________ No matter how finely you slice something up, it always has two sides. |
|
Karma: 13164.80 
Back to top |
|
 |
Pujakins Poet


    
Joined: Jun 19, 2010 Posts: 1068 Credits: 206 Location: North Grafton MA

|
Posted: Thu May 31 20:42:26 EDT 2012 Post subject: Re: Comments, reflections, suggestions? rewrites OK too--Thanks! |
|
OK, I think you are probably right and my use of the tumbled sentence is too obscure. So now I will have it thus:
Beyond our knowing,
stars move through the sky,
and heaven sweeps up the tears of love
making rainbows to comfort the woebegone.
Beyond our knowing,
birds sing the sun down and up
wind sweeps up the day's dust
readying the world for sleep.
Beyond our knowing
time ticks off our years,
until we're done with sunrise and sunset
adding our bit of dust to all the rest.
Beyond our knowing
Spiders spin, life moves in rivers
down all the ways to be
while we in our littleness flow with its tide.
I appreciate your guidance. Warm thanks, with a hug, Tasha
_________________ Maintaining an attitude of gratitude is the the best way I know to have a rich, fulfilling life. |
|
Karma: 3823.30 
Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Forum FAQ
|